Universal Health Services: Woman Wins Appeal in Wrongful Death Lawsuit Against UHS Hill Crest Psych Hospital

March 30, 2020

An Alabama woman on March 13 won her appeal of a wrongful death action she initially lost on behalf of a military veteran relative who died in a psychiatric hospital.

Fannie M. Pollard sued Hill Crest Behavioral Health Services, alleging in her complaint that improperly administering the antipsychotic drugs Haldol and Thorazine to her son-in-law’s brother Ed Young, as a chemical restraint, caused his death on May 9, 2015.

“The style of the complaint indicated that it was filed by the Estate of Ed Young and Fannie M. Pollard as personal representative of the Estate of Ed Young,” wrote Alabama Supreme Court Associate Justice Michael F. Bolin in the court’s decision.

“On May 8, 2017, the probate court appointed Fannie M. Pollard as administrator of Young's estate. On May 9, 2017, the two-year limitations period under Alabama's wrongful-death act expired.”

The Jefferson Circuit Court ruled against Pollard after Hill Crest psychiatric hospital filed a summary judgment motion arguing that Pollard was not the personal representative of Young's estate when the complaint was filed and that she lacked the capacity to bring suit.

“The Court finds that any purported amendment to substitute the personal representative as the proper plaintiff must fail, because a person who is not properly appointed as personal representative cannot bring a wrongful death lawsuit,” stated the Jefferson Circuit Court in its summary judgment favoring Hill Crest.

However, the Alabama Supreme Court reversed and remanded the trial court’s summary judgment on with one dissent on the part of Associate Supreme Court Justice James Gregory Shaw.

“Although Pollard was later made the personal representative, I see no authority indicating that this converts a null action into a viable case,” stated Justice Shaw in the dissent. “Thus, Pollard, in her new capacity as the personal representative, could not be substituted as the proper plaintiff or ratify her prior actions because there is no lawsuit in which she could do so in the first place.”

Source: “Alabama woman wins appeal in wrongful death action against psychiatric hospital,” Legal Newsline, March 24, 2020. URL: https://legalnewsline.com/stories/528223871-alabama-woman-wins-appeal-in-wrongful-death-action-against-psychiatric-hospital